[Indexed as: Internet America v. Internet Amercia]
[Indexed as: internetamerica.com]
WIPO Arbitration and Mediation Center
Administrative Panel Decision
Case No. D2000-0355
Commenced: 16 May 2000
Judgement: 19 June 2000
Presiding Panelist: Richard W. Page
Domain name Domain name dispute resolution policy Service mark Identical Confusingly similar Legitimate rights Bad faith registration Bad faith use.
Complainant was the registered owner of the service mark INTERNET AMERICA and has continually done business under that name since 1995. Respondent registered the name internetamerica.com. Complainant alleged that Respondents registered name is identical with and confusingly similar to its service marks; that Respondent has no rights to the name; and that Respondent registered and used the name in bad faith.
Held, Name Transferred to Complainant.
Complainant is the sole owner of the service mark INTERNET AMERICA.
Respondents domain name is identical with and confusingly similar to the
service marks INTERNET AMERICA.
Respondent has not acquired permission from Complainant to use its
registered mark. There is also no evidence that Respondent used the
name in connection with a bona fide offering of goods or services.
Thus, Respondent has no rights or legitimate interests in the domain name.
Respondent registered and used the name in bad faith as evidenced
by its lack of response to Complainants communications, and to the Administrative
Proceeding. Respondent also failed to post any content on the website,
or to take any action to use the name. These inactions infer bad
faith registration and use.
Policies referred to
Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy
Page, Panelist: -
1. The Parties
Complainant Internet America, Inc., a Texas corporation, whose principal
place of business is 350 North St. Paul, Suite 3000, Dallas, Texas 75201,
USA.
Respondent is "Internet America" an unknown type of entity purportedly
located at 3785 16th Street, San Francisco, California 94114, USA. Respondent
has not provided a telephone number, facsimile number or email address
in its domain name registration
2. The Domain Name(s) and Registrar(s)
The domain name at issue is <internetamerica.com >. The registrar
is Network Solutions, Inc. (the "Registrar") 505 Huntmar Park Drive, Herndon,
Virginia 20170-5139, USA.
3. Procedural History
The WIPO Arbitration and Mediation Center (the "Center") received the
Complaint of Complainants on April 28, 2000 by email and on May 1, 2000
in hardcopy. The Complainants paid the required fee. On May 5, 2000, the
Center sent an Acknowledgement of Receipt of the Complaint.
On May 5, 2000, the Center sent to the Registrar a request for verification
of registration data. On March 11, 2000, the Registrar confirmed, inter
alia, that it is the registrar of the domain name in dispute and that <internetamerica.com>
is registered in the Respondents name.
On May 11, 2000, the Center verified that the Complaint satisfies the
formal requirements of the ICANN Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution
Policy (the "Policy"), the Rules for Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution
Policy (the "Rules"), and the Supplemental Rules for Uniform Domain Name
Dispute Resolution Policy (the "Supplemental Rules"). On May 18, 2000,
the Center sent a Notification of Complaint and Commencement of Administrative
Proceeding to the Respondent together with copies of the Complaint, with
a copy to the Complainant. This notification was sent by the methods required
under paragraph 2(a) of the Rules. The formal date of the commencement
of this administrative proceeding is May 16, 2000.
On June 5, 2000, the Center received a completed and signed Statement
of Acceptance and Declaration of Impartiality and Independence from Richard
W. Page, Esq. (the "Presiding Panelist").
On June 6, 2000, the Center sent Notification of Respondents Default.
No Response has been received.
On June 7, 2000, the Center notified the parties of the appointment
of a single-arbitrator panel consisting of the Presiding Panelist.
4. Factual Background
Complainant is an Internet service provider (or "ISP") that provides
Internet services to individual and business subscribers. Its primary service
offering is dial-up and broadband Internet access and related value added-services.
Complainants stock is publicly traded on NASDAQ under the symbol GEEK.
Complainant was originally incorporated in Arizona as "The Net, Inc."
on December 13, 1994. On January 18, 1995, Complainant filed an amendment
with the Arizona Secretary of State, changing its corporate name to "Internet
America, Inc." On July 21, 1995, Internet America, Inc. was merged with
Intrnetusa, Inc., a Texas corporation. The surviving corporation was Internet
America, Inc., a Texas corporation. Complainant has continually done business
under the name "Internet America" since January of 1995.
Complainant has continuously used the service mark INTERNET AMERICA
in interstate commerce throughout the United States since January of 1995.
Complainant owns the following registration and application for its INTERNET
AMERICA service mark:
- INTERNET AMERICA (word), Reg. No. 1,151,607, filed June 13, 1995
and registered on April 21, 1998 for "providing multiple user access to
a global computer network for the transfer and dissemination of a wide
range of information" in International Class 42; and
- INTERNET AMERICA & Design, Serial No. 75/523013, filed July 21,
1998 for "providing multiple user access to a global computer network for
the transfer and dissemination of a wide range of information" in International
Class 42.
Complainants registration is in full force and effect, and use of
the mark has not been abandoned.
Respondent is not a licensee of Complainant, and has not received any
permission or consent to use the service mark INTERNET AMERICA or apply
for the domain name <internetamerica .com>. Other than as listed in
the WHOIS database maintained by Network Solutions, Inc., Respondent is
not (either as an individual, business or other organization) known by
the name INTERNET AMERICA. Further, there is no evidence of the Respondents
use of, or demonstrable preparations to use, the disputed domain name or
a name corresponding to <internet america.com> in connection with a
bona fide offering of goods or services. The disputed domain name does
not resolve (and never has resolved) to a website or other online presence.
In a letter dated April 12, 2000, Complainant (through its legal representative)
offered Respondent the opportunity to provide any evidence that might demonstrate
Respondents rights or legitimate interests to <internetamerica.com>.
The correspondence to Respondent dated April 12, 2000 remains unanswered.
5. Parties Contentions
Complainants contend that the domain name <internetamerica.com>
is identical with and confusingly similar to Complainants INTERNET AMERICA
service marks pursuant to the Policy paragraph 4(a)(i).
Complainants contend that Respondent has no rights or legitimate interest
in the domain name <internetamerica.com> pursuant to the Policy paragraph
4(a)(ii).
Complainant contends that Respondent registered and is using the domain
name <internetamerica.com> in bad faith in violation of the Policy paragraph
4(a)(iii).
Respondent presented no evidence challenging that the domain name <internetameric.com>
is identical with or confusingly similar to the INTERNET AMERICA service
marks.
Respondent presented no evidence of its rights or legitimate interest
in <internetamerica.com> domain name.
Respondent presented no evidence that its registration and use of the
<internetamerica.com> domain name is in good faith.
6. Discussion and Findings
Even though Respondent has filed no Response and has offered no evidence
attacking the contentions of Claimants, the Presiding Panelist hereby reviews
the evidence before him to determine whether the Claimants have supported
each of the required elements in its contentions within the existing record.
Identity or Confusing Similarity.
Complainant is the sole and exclusive owners of the United States registered
service mark INTERNET AMERICA (word) (Reg. No. 1,151,607) and INTERNET
AMERICA & Design (Serial No. 75/523013). The domain name <internetamerica.com>
contains the identical phrase "Internet America." Therefore, the Presiding
Panelist finds that the domain name <internetamerica.com> is identical
with and confusingly similar to the service marks INTERNET AMERICA pursuant
to the Policy paragraph 4(a)(i).
Rights or Legitimate Interest.
Respondent is not a licensee of Complainant, and has not received any
permission or consent to use the service marks INTERNET AMERICA or to apply
for the domain name <internetamerica .com>. There is no evidence of
the Respondents use of, or demonstrable preparations to use, the disputed
domain name or a name corresponding to <internetamerica.com> in connection
with a bona fide offering of goods or services. The disputed domain name
does not resolve (and never has resolved) to a website or other online
presence. Therefore, the Presiding Panelist finds that Respondent has no
rights or legitimate interest in the domain name <internetamerica.com>
pursuant to the Policy paragraph 4(a)(ii).
Bad Faith.
Respondents failure (1) to respond to the inquiries of Complainant
or to the Notification of Complaint and Commencement of Administrative
Proceeding sent by the Center, (2) to respond to Complainants communciations,
(3) to post any content on a website or to use the disputed domain name
and (4) to take any action and the mere passive holding of the disputed
domain name support the inference that the registration and the use of
the domain name <internetamerica .com> has been in bad faith. Therefore,
the Presiding Panelist finds that the registration and use of the domain
name <internetamerica.com> is in bad faith pursuant to the Policy paragraph
4(a)(iii).
7. Decision
The Presiding Panelist concludes (a) that the domain name <internetamerica.com>
is identical with and confusingly similar to the service marks INTERNET
AMERICA, (b) that Respondent has no rights or legitimate interest in the
domain name and (c) that Respondent registered and used the domain name
in bad faith. Therefore, pursuant to paragraphs 4(i) of the Policy and
15 of the Rules, the Panel orders that the domain name <internetamerica.com>
be transferred to Complainant Internet America, Inc.
Domain Name Transferred